» Inhaltsübersicht
Hub-Article
9 Min.

Robots as Co-Surgeons in the Operating Room

Robotics in Healthcare – Opportunities, Challenges, Outlooks

Robotics is increasingly finding its way into hospitals and changing everyday life for both medical staff and patients. From automated transport systems to robotic assistance systems in surgery, robotics is being used in various areas of medicine. It is utilized to optimize processes, relieve workloads and support medical interventions. A key area of application is the operating room, where robot-assisted systems are increasingly gaining in importance. Surgical robots are used for minimally invasive procedures and enable precision work in areas that are particularly challenging for surgeons. Surgical robotic systems do not act independently, but support doctors and surgeons with enhanced mobility and visualization options.

We spoke to three experts with different perspectives on robotics in hospitals. Dr. Jochen Jung is a senior orthopedic surgeon at the ATOS Clinic in Heidelberg. He is one of the few physicians to perform robot-assisted hip replacement surgery and is a sought-after instructor for hip replacement robotics throughout Europe. Dirk Barten is senior vice president and general manager, E.U. commercial and marketing expert at Intuitive. As Managing Director of Intuitive Surgical in Germany and Austria and Head of the Central and Eastern Europe region, he is responsible for the robotics business, which includes the Da Vinci surgical robot. Dr. Dennis Kundrat is head of research at the Fraunhofer Institute for Individualized and Cell-based Medical Technology IMTE. Under hisHospital information systems (HIS) encompass all information and communication systems within a hospital. These electronic systems enable the capture, storage, processing, and long-term use of data. Both medical and administrative data are made accessible to all staff within the hospital.Further purposes of hospital information systems include incr… Explained in the video. leadership, the Fraunhofer IMTE is establishing the Lübeck Innovation Hub for Robotic Surgery (LIROS), a unique research center with close interdisciplinary links to the University Medical Center Schleswig-Holstein for robot-assisted surgery, with a realistic operating environment, modern high-end equipment and individual anatomical patient models.

What excites you about robots in medicine?

Dr. Jochen Jung: The combination of innovative technology and people to provide the best possible care for our patients. Technology helps us do this with unprecedented precision for the patient. It helps me implement modern strategies for implanting hip and knee replacements.

Dirk Barten: I am fascinated by robotic-assisted surgical systems because they are changing the way we treat patients today. The efficiency of robotic-assisted surgery helps surgeons and their care teams provide more minimally invasive care to patients, which can lead to benefits such as faster recovery times and shorter hospital stays for many procedures. Robotics can also support further efficiencies in hospitals by allowing more flexible use of staff. The future is also very exciting: Technologies such as artificial intelligence,Artificial Intelligence (AI) implies the attempt to transfer human learning and thinking to computers. Computer systems are intended to solve problems—for which a human would require intelligence—using large datasets. In the field of radiology, for example, artificial intelligence can assist physicians in diagnosing findings and detecting abnormali… Explained in the video. advanced imaging and data analytics can further improve the efficiency of surgery and support the training of our surgeons and teams.

Dr. Dennis Kundrat: Since the beginning of my career, I have been fascinated and motivated by the realization of robotic platforms that enable new minimally invasive surgical techniques and become intelligent instruments in the process. Ideally, these platforms complement or augment the capabilities of humans, enabling innovative care concepts. My professional stations in medical robotics research have always given me the opportunity to continuously develop state-of-the-art technologies and thus actively contribute to the medicine of tomorrow.

What OR robotics applications do you use or develop in your organization?

Dr. Jochen Jung: I use a robotic arm system that helps me carry out the pre-planning very precisely in the operating room. This consists of two main components, first the three-dimensional planning of both the hip and knee joint, and then the transfer of the data to the operating room and the very precise execution on the patient. I use the MAKO Robotic System from Stryker, MAKO is derived from MAKO Hais (the company started as MAKO Robotics in Ft. Lauderdale/FL).

Dirk Barten: Intuitive is a global leader in minimally invasive medical care and a pioneer in robotic-assisted surgery. Our technologies include the da Vinci Surgical System and the Ion Endoluminal System for robotic-assisted bronchoscopy. Using digital intelligence, we can combine our advanced systems, advanced learning and value-added services to help physicians and their teams optimize care and achieve the best possible outcomes. Our technologies enable minimally invasive procedures with high precision, improved clinical outcomes and potentially shorter recovery times for patients, while the systems remain under physician control and do not act autonomously.

Dr. Dennis Kundrat: At our research center in Lübeck, we currently use commercial platforms such as Medtronic Hugo and Distal Motion Dexter, which are also available in the UKSH operating rooms. The focus here is on new training technologies and workflow development, as well as the development of our own platforms for prototyping. This includes innovative robotic minimally invasive procedures for visceral, orthopedic and trauma surgery. We are also developing innovative training concepts that address the digital transformation of manual and robotic surgery (phantoms, VR,Virtual Reality (VR) offers a unique visualization context that enhances the perception of volumetric details. Unlike conventional monitor-based visualization, where users typically observe three-dimensional (3D) data as passive observers, VR’s immersive experience allows users to enter their data in a spatially realistic way. First-time VR e… Explained in the video. AR)Augmented Reality (AR) enables an extension of reality, enriched by technically generated virtual information that can address all human senses. At any point in time, however, the individual reality of the user remains central and is experienced in real time — it is never fully replaced by the digital layer. AR is most commonly implemented …… and, in particular, the shortage of medical specialists. We additionally work on automation concepts for mechatronic assistance systems in medicine.

How can hospitals use robots to improve quality?

Dr. Jochen Jung: In my field of orthopedics, we are particularly interested in standardized operations, such as the implantation of artificial hip and knee joints, but also shoulder joints, spinal surgery (here the insertion of screws) or the implantation of rarer joints, such as artificial elbow joints or upper ankle joints. The more complex the operation becomes, e.g. with exchangeable prostheses, the more I see the performance of the systems reaching their limits.

Dirk Barten: The use of robotic systems in hospitals can offer many benefits, including increased precision. Equipped with innovative technology, the da Vinci Surgical System scales, filters and translates the surgeon’s hand movements at the console into precise instrument movements. The EndoWrist instruments can be moved with more degrees of freedom than the human hand, providing greater access to the surgical area. The endoscope provides the surgeon with an HD 3D view that is magnified up to ten times. This can lead to better patient outcomes. Studies show that robotic-assisted surgeries often result in lower complication rates, less blood loss and faster recovery times. The systems also offer benefits to surgeons, such as ergonomics, efficiency through standardization, and enhanced training through online simulation and telementoring.

In lung cancer diagnostics, the Ion System’s ultra-thin, highly flexible robotic catheter uses unique shape-sensing technology to enable physicians to reach deep, hard-to-reach areas of the lung. Once there, the system’s stability allows tissue to be removed for biopsy with greater precision and accuracy than manual bronchoscopes. Ion’s ability to access small and hard-to-reach lung cavities and remove tissue can help improve early diagnosis of patients with suspected lung cancer.

Dr. Dennis Kundrat: The quality of robotic surgery depends on many factors. For certain cases, such as prostatectomies, there is already evidence from studies showing the advantages of robotic surgery over conventional surgery. However, it is important to note that this evidence has not yet been fully established for a large number of cases. In addition, similar to manual surgery, the outcome is highly dependent on the level of robotic training. Standard training is carried out at selected training centers, but in the future it may be based on low-threshold and cost-effective approaches, such as those we are pursuing at the Fraunhofer IMTE. One component of the quality of robotic surgery that has received little attention to date is the ethical perspective. Comprehensive patient education in the context of new technologies and the management of exaggerated expectations have received little attention. In the long term, new monitoring tools should be established for robotic surgery that allow critical evaluation of clinical outcomes and other effects.

What risks need to be considered when using surgical robotics?

Dr. Jochen Jung: Overall, the current orthopedic robotic systems on the market are relatively mature. There are potential complications, such as the implantation of additional antenna systems/infrared reflectors, but in my experience these have been relatively manageable since 2017. The old robotic systems used in the early 2000s (Robodoc, Caspar) had significant complications. In my opinion, a particular problem at the moment is the education and training of younger surgeons, some of whom are then completely dependent on the robotic system and are relatively helpless if a system fails. This means that with very young surgeons who have direct contact with robotics, I see the problem that they will eventually lose their “skills”. The failure of a system must always be considered, so there must always be a backup to continue the operation manually.

Dirk Barten: Physicians are at the heart of robotic-assisted technology. The systems act as an extension of the surgeon’s arm. Intuitive is committed to helping hospitals, physicians and surgical teams implement their robotic-assisted surgery programs. Our customers are supported by the entire Intuitive ecosystem, which includes a comprehensive and ongoing technology training program, continuous on-call technical support and customer-focused maintenance strategies to maximize system uptime, and digital tools and analytics to help track costs, utilization and outcomes and identify opportunities for further optimization. In general, it can be said that there are risks associated with any surgery, but with robotic-assisted surgery, the surgeon is always in control.

Dr. Dennis Kundrat: The risks associated with the use of robotic systems in surgery are complex. In general, most of the risks can be significantly reduced by intensive training of the entire surgical team. Manufacturers of commercial systems typically provide extensive training to ensure a seamless transition to conventional surgery in the event of an emergency. Technical risks are also reduced by coordinated maintenance programs. However, even with complex mechatronic systems, malfunctions can occur in everyday clinical practice that can disrupt the surgical workflow and prevent the continuation of the robotic procedure. In this context, full acceptance and trust on the part of the user and the patient are crucial. If these issues are not addressed, e.g. frequent system failures that repeatedly disrupt the surgical workflow, there is a high risk that the platforms will not be accepted by clinical staff in the long term. Similar scenarios have led to the withdrawal of platforms from the market on several occasions. The use of robotic systems that enable multimodal data acquisition (image, sound, input) also raises questions about data protection risks. In particular, technology ethics is called upon to critically examine the risks in the area of patient autonomyAutonomy, or autonomous, refers in a technical context particularly to independence and self-sufficiency. Autonomous robots, for example, respond to their environment and are in this sense self-directed, whereby different degrees of autonomy may exist. as well as the changed working environment for clinical staff.

How will OR robotics affect the labor market?

Dr. Jochen Jung: In my opinion, robotics will not significantly reduce the number of personnel required in the operating room at this time. Today’s systems are assistive systems, which only support partial steps of the operation, but do not offer a replacement. In the future, one could imagine optical systems that hold retractors, for example, and could actually replace human labor. However, this is unlikely to happen in the near future, as the standard level of alertness in the operating room is very limited.

Dirk Barten: We know that the shortage of skilled personnel in hospitals is a problem. Robot-assisted surgery can help make operating room staff more flexible, in some cases reducing the need for operating room staff and freeing them up for other tasks. For some procedures, robot-assisted surgery can reduce the length of hospital stay. This can reduce the burden on nursing staff and even allow more patients to be cared for. Increased use of robotic surgical systems can provide ergonomic benefits for surgeons and reduce the burden on the surgical team.

Dr. Dennis Kundrat: An increase in robotic surgery will place new demands on the labor market, but will not have a direct impact on the shortage of specialists. This includes in particular a change in training concepts for physicians and a change in training programs and content for OR personnel. This also affects the entire communication in the OR teams (decentralized distribution of the team). It remains to be seen whether the partially improved ergonomics at the console will allow for longer healthy working hours in a large number of procedures (evidence is still pending).

What new skills do people working in the OR need for the use of robotics?

Dr. Jochen Jung: The training must first be done on the system in use. I have the privilege of conducting many certification courses for surgeons. It is clear that experienced surgeons adapt very quickly to the new technology and accept the partial steps performed by the robotics relatively easily and appreciate the support. In particular, the unfamiliarity and cooperation with the technology requires a certain amount of familiarization, but experience shows that the learning curve is very steep. No special skills are required.

Dirk Barten: Surgeons are constantly learning and improving their skills. All surgeons who operate a da Vinci system have completed medical training, which is typically supplemented by a comprehensive technology training program from Intuitive. They are also guided through their learning curve by experienced proctors. However, training is not limited to the direct users – as the use of a da Vinci system is a team effort, training modules are offered for all members of the surgical team. It is recommended that a robotics coordinator be appointed to optimize the processes surrounding robotic programs in the clinic.

Dr. Dennis Kundrat: In addition to participation in appropriate training programs, openness, acceptance and tolerance towards new technologies in the healthcare sector is essential. In the course of my professional career, I have not noticed any generational dependency, as might have been expected. The robotic platforms – all of which are complex mechatronic systems – require the continuous acquisition of new skills for the setup, installation and use in everyday clinical practice. In addition, OR management must be adapted to the new technologies and emergency management must be changed (conversion to conventional procedures must be established) in order to achieve sustainable success with the clinical robotics programs and to further develop OR teams in the long term.

Further information on the topic

The ATLAS contains further articles and science digests on surgical robotics and other areas of application in the healthcare sector:

  • Knee surgery robots – a win-win situation for all parties? Link
  • Micro and nanorobots: science fiction or soon to be reality? Link
  • Robotics in home care: How can caregivers be relieved? Link

 

Contact
Chair of Management and
Innovation in Healthcare
Witten/Herdecke University
Alfred-Herrhausen-Straße 50
58448 Witten, Germany